ECM Sports Bar

[ikethegreat]

By favorite quote:

"Then, last year, the Colts went from perennial playoff participants with Manning to the worst team in the league without him, adding fuel to the assertion that no quarterback has ever been more valuable than No. 18. Indy's dramatic decline, along with the fact that the Patriots managed to go 11-5 with Matt Cassel filling in for Brady in '08, created a Manning is the greatest argument I have found it extremely difficult to rebut. "

AGREED! 

[ikethegreat]

I'm pretty upset I won't get to see the game though.  I wish it was the sunday night or monday night game.   

[Mike]

By favorite quote:

"Then, last year, the Colts went from perennial playoff participants with Manning to the worst team in the league without him, adding fuel to the assertion that no quarterback has ever been more valuable than No. 18. Indy's dramatic decline, along with the fact that the Patriots managed to go 11-5 with Matt Cassel filling in for Brady in '08, created a Manning is the greatest argument I have found it extremely difficult to rebut. "

AGREED! 

I'll read it later but, I put the drop off more on the GM. They were stupid and didnt have a decent backup. They spent the mo.eg else where and got caught doing so. Most NFL teams have a backup that's decent.

[accordguy04]

What the fuuuuuck!  Mobile blackout?  Are you fucking kidding me?  I cant listen to the game on my phone and NFL mobile wont even update to tell me what the score is... this fucking blows.

(sry, it pertained to sports and phone stuff so I wasnt sure where to post)

[Mike]

Peyton coming up short as usuall. His 4 -9 record head to head is just fucking amazing... Just saying...

[ikethegreat]

Greatest QB ≠ Greatest team

[Mike]

Just not true... Give it up. Doesn't have enough wins when it matters. 1 superbowl is not enough to be the greatest. End of story

[gargantula99]

Who's the greatest?

[status]

Statistically right now , in this season is stupid Alex smith.

[gargantula99]

Not statistically for this season, just in general. Hopefully this won't turn into a flacco and Brady dispute.

[ikethegreat]

Of all time?  It is hard to say, especially with three of the top contenders still currently playing in the NFL. 

Statistically speaking you'd probably have to go with Favre just because he holds most of the QB records right now.  Personally I'm not even sure he even belongs in the top 10 all time QBs though.  When you play as long as he did, it really shouldn't be surprising he holds all those records. 

[Mike]

Honestly IMO...

Montana
Brady
Manning

[ikethegreat]

What about Brees?   He broke the passing yards record last year, has a SB win, was instrumental in ending the lockout,  and just broke Johnny U's consecutive games with a TD streak.  I think he always gets overshadowed by Manning and Brady.  

[Mike]

He's good but his career stats won't get to the level of the others. Not to mention the way his team is playi.g this year. It's tough to compare guys. Then theres the dome conversation... Who are the top 5 current qb's.

Rogers
Brady
Brees
Manning
Manning

[ikethegreat]

BLANK has been one of the most efficient passers in NFL history. He currently ranks 10th all-time in NFL passer rating (92.9), 5th in yards per attempt (8.06), and 11th in completion percentage (63.24%) among quarterbacks with a minimum of 1,500 career attempts. He has the fourth highest career winning percentage (.710) as a starter in the regular season among quarterbacks with a minimum of 100 starts.

Fill in the blank with the name of a two time superbowl winning QB.  Hint - he isn't on your list.